The Muffy Cookie
However much I love cookies, they’re easily equated with drudgery in the food prep world. A large batch of batter can be made and a few may be baked off right away, but it’s awfully convenient to enlist a person, arm her with an ice cream scoop, and instruct her to scoop the batter into little mounds in interminable rows onto baking sheets. They can then be frozen and baked fresh as needed, but the beauty of the individual cookie is easily lost in the process.
So, I was happy to find Isabella’s Cookies at Cooke’s Market in El Segundo, Los Angeles, which has rejuvenated my jaded cookie sensibility. These are cookies are sold in markets across LA. My favorite so far is the Muffy Cookie. It had white chocolate, blueberries, and milk chocolate covered blueberries, and it has the uncanny taste of a blueberry muffin. The dough part seems to have a little less brown sugar than the dough of a chocolate chip cookie, and I think that the particular sweetness of the white chocolate somehow helps to evoke the muffin flavor.
The Twister is another good one — chocolate toffee pieces with chunks of milk chocolate. I’m looking forward to getting my hands on their CranApple Fritter Cookie, with oatmeal, apples, cranberries, white chocolate chips, and cinnamon.
Isabella’s Cookies seem like the Ben & Jerry’s of the cookie world. Made out of an eclectic mix of wholesome ingredients (unbleached flour, fresh butter and eggs, no preservatives, no hydrogenated oils or high fructose corn syrup), they’re fun and tasty. They’re moist and voluminous, but a little less sweet than cookies normally found in supermarkets, so they taste like real food… and are very addictive. They also make me want to play around with doughs and flavorings of cookies more…


June 7th, 2006 at 5:41 pm
I wish they had those out here (Colorado). I’m currently in the middle of a craving for large, crumbly cookies just like that one.
June 13th, 2006 at 5:16 pm
Oh, Isabella’s would be happy to send you some! That’s how I get my fix in Northern California! Mocha Monster, Maui Wowie and Rocky Road for me! GREAT cookies!
June 14th, 2006 at 4:03 pm
Ooh, there’s another really good cookie that they sell at Whole Foods here in So. Cal and of course I can’t remember the name of them at the moment. They are outrageously expensive but worth it. I’ll get that name and the name of my favorite cookie when I go shopping sometime this week. In the meantime, fie on you for now making me want these REALLY badly! I am a cookie monster…!
June 15th, 2006 at 1:17 pm
Just found a Muffy Cookie! I was having lunch at Shoop’s Deli in Santa Monica, and there it was. I’m saving it for later, though. Probably not a good thing that I know where to get a fix. However, now you do too when you come south…
June 17th, 2006 at 6:53 am
From Our Kitchen - One of these days, I hope to develop a recipe for a similar cookie, so hopefully, either by mail order or baking, they’ll find their way around.
Tasha - Thanks for letting us all know! Hehe “Cookies by mail” is such a brilliant thing.
Susuan - Cool! Let me know the name of that cookie. And I hope that you enjoyed the Muffy Cookie!
January 19th, 2008 at 12:44 pm
MUFFY, MUFFY, MUFFY!! I love this cookie soo much. It takes like cookies mom use to make. I get my cookies from Famina market in Pasadena
January 25th, 2008 at 11:04 am
hehe Isn’t that a great name!
And now I have a craving…